For almost two months, our explore pages, timelines, and for you pages have been inundated with graphic videos and images from the latest conflict between Israel and Palestine. Bowing under public pressure, celebrities and other high profile figures rushed to social media to make carefully crafted statements containing a very specific trio of comments: that they condemn violence, denounce Hamas, and will call out antisemitism. Though, for your average Joe who has no PR team, taking a hard stance on the issue (whether pro-Israel or pro-Palestine) has had wider implications, because it’s often meant the difference between being employed or unemployed.
US universities
University students across the US who denounced the Israeli government and drew attention to the plight of the Palestinian people were met with outrage, particularly by alumni and university donors.
A group of Harvard student organisations who referred to themselves as the Palestinian Solidarity Groups published a since-deleted letter condemning the Israeli government, per The Harvard Crimson. Part of their statement read: “The apartheid regime is the only one to blame.”
Following the intense backlash stemming from the letter, Claudine Gay, Harvard’s president, stated that the university “rejects terrorism”, but that it also “embraces a commitment to free expression”. Her words did little to soothe the concerns of many prominent donors, including the Wexner Foundation, a nonprofit started by Victoria’s Secret founder Leslie Wexner. CNN later reported that the Foundation, in protest, ended its relationship with Harvard.
Idan and Batia Ofer (an Israeli billionaire couple) stepped down from their roles on the board of the Harvard Kenny School, stating that their “faith in the university’s leadership has been broken.”
Other prominent figures like hedge-fund manager Bill Ackman and Sweetgreen CEO Jonathan Neman called for the names of the students involved in the groups to be made public, with Neman writing on X (formerly Twitter): “I would like to know so I know never to hire these people.”
Following this, conservative advocacy group, Accuracy In Media, had a billboard truck drive around the Harvard campus displaying the names and faces of all the students who signed the letter, labelling them antisemites. The students were then doxxed by several websites. Over a third of the 34 co-signing clubs withdrew their signatures from the statement, and some claimed they hadn’t read the statement before signing.
Several professors from various universities urged employers not to hire students who expressed support for Palestine. Steven Davidoff Solomon, a law professor at the University of California, wrote an opinion column for The Wall Street Journal saying that firms should not hire his own pro-Palestinian students.
A professor at the Washington University School of Medicine claimed that he was fired for posting a now-deleted comment on X that said the Hamas attacks were a “much needed cleansing, yes, but not an ethnic one. Israel is not targeting humans.” It was subsequently revealed that the professor is still employed, and that his comments were reportedly referring to Hamas specifically.
In September this year, the American Jewish Committee accused several speakers of making antisemitic remarks, in particular highlighting CUNY professor Marc Lamont Hill, who was previously fired from CNN speech calling for world leaders to support a free Palestine, per NBC News.
A petition was published and signed by close to 80,000 people for the immediate removal of Columbia University professor Joseph Massad of the Department of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies. Signatories took issue with an article he’d written that described Hamas’ October attacks as “resistance offensive” to “Israeli settler-colonialism and racism toward the Palestinians.”
Likewise, Yale University’s Zareena Grewal (an associate professor of American studies and related fields of ethnicity, race and migration, and religious studies) sparked outrage due to her posts supporting Palestinian resistance.
A statement from Stanford University detailed that an instructor was removed following comments made about Israel being a coloniser. CNN reported that the teacher allegedly asked their class how many Jews were killed in the Holocaust, to which a student replied six million, before the teacher stated that more people had been killed by colonisers like Israel. Several students were also reportedly told to stand at the back of the class because “that’s what Israel does to Palestinians.”
Cornell history professor Russell J. Rickford is on a leave of absence following a speech he gave at an off-campus pro-Palestine rally. “What I was referring to is in those first few hours, when they broke through the apartheid wall, that it seemed to be a symbol of resistance, and indeed a new phase of resistance in the Palestinian struggle,” he said in defence of his words. He has since apologised for making “reckless” comments.
University of California’s assistance professor of American studies is currently under investigation for an X post she wrote that called out “zionist journalists who spread propaganda & misinformation” and adding that “they can fear their bosses but they should fear us more.” The university’s chancellor Gary S. May called her words “revolting.”
At work
The New York Post has detailed how Philadelphia-based sports journalist, Jackson Frank, lost his job at PhillyVoice.com following a comment he made on X that contradicted the 76ers’ statement in support of Israel, a team he regularly covers. “Solidarity with Palestine always,” he wrote.
The Davis Polk law firm in New York reportedly rescinded job offers to three students from Columbia and Harvard, following news that they had issued statements in support of Palestine. According to NBC News, part of the email read: “These statements are simply contrary to our firm’s values and we thus concluded that rescinding these offers was appropriate in upholding our responsibility to provide a safe and inclusive work environment for all Davis Polk employees.”
Samira Nasr, editor-in-chief of Harper’s Bazaar, was forced to issue an apology after deeming Israel’s decision to cut off water to Gaza “the most inhuman thing I’ve seen in my life,” per The New York Post. Hearst Magazines, the media company that produces Harper’s Bazaar, then sent employees an email explaining that Nasr’s comments were not reflective of the company’s values.
Maha Dakhil was forced to step down from her role as co-head of the motion picture department at Creative Arts Agency, as well as resigned from the company’s internal board, after she shared two Instagram posts that referred to Israel’s attacks as “genocide,” per the Los Angeles Times.
After sharing a satirical article titled “Dying Gazans Criticized For Not Using Last Words To Condemn Hamas” by The Onion, Michael Eisen, editor-in-chief of the eLife medical journal, revealed that he’d been fired. He later added that he believed The Onion “speaks with more courage, insight and moral clarity than the leaders of every academic institution put together.”
In culture spaces
Multiple events promoting books based on stories of the mistreatment of Palestinians in Israel were cancelled, as well as pro-Palestinian film festivals.
The Guardian detailed how the Frankfurt Book Fair cancelled a ceremony that would be honouring Adania Shibli, a Palestinian author, with an award called LiBeraturpreis – an accolade that recognises female authors in Latin America, Africa, and Asia- Shibli had won the award for her 2017 historical fiction novel Minor Detail, which details the capture and rape of a Palestinian teenager by Israeli soldiers after the War of Independence in 1949.
Nathan Thrall’s latest novel, A Day in the Life of Abed Salama, which centres on the story of how a man’s search for his five-year-old son was affected by Israeli restrictions, also suffered after multiple book events were cancelled, per The Wire.
Both the Boston Palestine Film Festival and the Witness Palestine Film Festival were cancelled and moved online.
